The short-term rental sector faces a new reality

From pandemic boom to growing pains - why reputation, consistency, and hotel-like standards are now essential

The short-term rental sector (STR), once buoyed by pandemic-driven demand, is now experiencing stagnation and struggling to retain customer loyalty. Despite strong earnings from major players like Airbnb, the industry is under pressure due to inconsistent guest experiences, negative media coverage, and increased scrutiny—especially from younger travelers.

Key takeaways

• Market plateau: STR usage among U.S. leisure travelers has held steady at about 25% since 2020.
• Reputation issues: Negative press and inconsistent experiences have damaged the sector’s image.
• Lack of loyalty: Most STR users also stay in hotels or resorts and compare experiences across categories.
• Younger travelers skeptical: Under-35s question STR value and are more influenced by negative headlines.
• Trust erosion: Many hosts admit unprofessional practices have hurt consumer confidence.
• Hotel-Like standards expected: Guests increasingly expect STRs to match hotel service and reliability.
• Market saturation risk: Only high-quality operators are likely to thrive as expectations rise and inventory grows.
• Critical need for evolution: STRs must focus on transparency, consistency, and reputation to stay relevant.

Purchase the full report at Phocuswright