AI won't commoditize your hotel. It commoditizes being found.
The industry is reassuring itself that AI can't flatten the guest experience. It's right — and it's guarding the wrong layer
by Markus Busch
A PhocusWire panel took up the question of whether AI will commoditize hospitality, and reached a comfortable consensus: AI itself isn't the differentiator. The edge lives in data, the tech stack, and customer ownership, and the "last mile" of service is human. All true. It's also aimed at the wrong layer.
They're defending the layer AI can't reach. There are two. The stay — the room, the service, the thing a guest actually feels — won't commoditize. Two hotels on the same model get different results, as Aven's Mark Hollyhead said, and Canary's Harman Singh Narula is right that the last mile is human. But the stay was never the layer at risk. The layer at risk is access to the guest: being discovered, compared, recommended. The reassuring consensus is about the half the panelists' products don't threaten.
The one who says it plainly is Shiji's Natalie Kimball. The guest is already owned — by the OTAs twenty years ago, and now by the AI agents that serve OTA results back. Commoditization is beside the point because the capture already happened, and it's replaying one layer up. That's the honest read, and it's ours. The panel debates whether AI flattens the experience. The money question is who controls whether your experience is ever shown to an agent to book.
"Differentiate through data" is the comfortable half of the answer. Express your uniqueness clearly, the panel advises; AI rewards clarity and relevance. That assumes the discovery layer is a meritocracy that pays out for being distinctive. It isn't. It rewards the established, and increasingly the paid. This week alone, Booking defended to a regulator its power to fund its own lowest price, and Hilton built its own agent-ready rails and chose who gets to connect. "Communicate who you are" is necessary and nowhere near sufficient against that. Clarity does not outrank a platform that can buy the top result.
The stake. So here's the honest answer to the panel's question. AI won't commoditize the stay. It will commoditize the independent hotel's control over being found — and hand that control to whoever owns discovery. The one hedge the panel underplays is the only durable one, precisely because no vendor can sell it to you: owning the guest relationship directly, the data and the demand you don't rent from a platform. Everything else is the hammer the panel opened with — and by definition, everyone else is holding the same one.
Enjoying this analysis? Hospitality.today delivers daily insights on hotel distribution, AI trends, and travel commerce — straight to your inbox. Subscribe for free at Hospitality.today →