The audience for your guest reviews is no longer a guest

Your reviews now answer the traveler's questions, sit in Google's booking conversation, and decide which hotel an assistant names. Almost nobody reads them.

by Markus Busch

Someone quoted a review to your front desk last month. She had read the one about the corner room and the church bells, and she asked for that room by number. It happens all the time. People still read reviews, and anyone who tells you otherwise has never stood behind a check-in desk on a Friday.

She is the last of something, and nobody has told her.

Your reviews are doing more work than they ever have

Think about what a review was in 2010. One night, one stranger's opinion, sitting in a list of three hundred others. It moved whoever happened to read it. That was the whole of its job.

Now look at what a paragraph a guest wrote about your breakfast is being asked to do.

It answers questions your reservations desk used to answer. Booking.com's Property Q&A has been live since October 2024 across the US, UK, Australia, New Zealand and Singapore. A traveler types a specific question — is there a charger for the car, will you take a big dog — and the answer comes back built out of your listing, your photos, and your guests' reviews. Nobody at your hotel was asked. Nobody at your hotel knows what was said.

It picks which parts of your hotel a traveler sees. Agoda put AI-curated review highlights on property pages in August, and does not say who curates them.

It sits inside the booking. Since August, Google's AI Mode has been booking hotel rooms in the middle of a conversation, showing the traveler reviews alongside the options it selected for her.

And it decides the name. When an assistant is asked where to stay in your town, it builds the answer out of the review sites, not out of your website — which we have covered before.

Four jobs. Twenty years ago a review had one, and it was the softest job on the internet. Every one of those four now runs on the text your guests typed, and every one of them is a place where your room gets sold or does not.

And almost nobody is reading them

The same companies putting that much weight on your reviews have spent two years building products whose stated purpose is that travelers stop reading them. Booking.com wrote it down in its own announcement: Review Summaries, so the traveler gets what matters without browsing through numerous reviews. That is not a side effect somebody noticed later. It is the design goal, on the record, from the largest seller of hotel rooms in the world.

Tripadvisor's version sits at the top of your page, above the reviews it was made from.

Tripadvisor is not fighting this. It is selling the exit.

Fewer people arrive at its hotel pages every quarter. That business shrank by a fifth this spring, and not because prices came down. Nobody came. So it found a better buyer for your reviews than the traveler. It has signed them over to the companies running the assistants, ChatGPT among them, and says the few people who arrive back through that door book more reliably than almost anyone else who walks in. An AI company that has not signed a deal cannot get at the reviews at all — Tripadvisor blocks it. Matt Goldberg, CEO of Tripadvisor, says the next thing under discussion is letting the partners train on the reviews, which no deal has allowed so far.

Your guests wrote about your rooms. Tripadvisor is selling what they wrote, you were never in the deal, and nobody is sending you a check.

The way in is no different. Of 31.1 million reviews submitted to Tripadvisor in 2024, 87.8% went live on automated screening alone, and roughly one in twenty reached a human moderator. Those are the company's own counts. So for nine reviews in ten, no person reads it on the way in either.

Written by a guest. Screened by software. Compressed by software. Read out by software to someone asking where to stay.

A review used to be reputation. It is now the file on your hotel

You have been managing reviews as reputation. A score to defend. A complaint to answer politely, in public, for the benefit of the next person reading down the page. That work assumed a reader, and the reader is leaving.

What replaced her is worse and better than she was. Worse, because she was persuadable and a summary is not. Better, because she read four reviews and moved on, while the machinery reads all nine hundred of yours, every time, and keeps what it finds.

So your reviews are not your reputation any more. They are the file on your hotel. What you are and what you have, written down by strangers, held on platforms you do not control, and read by every system that decides whether to sell your room. You did not write a line of it. It outranks everything you did write.

What this changes at your front desk

She tells your GM on the way out that it was the best week of her year. That is the moment, and what you ask for in it has to change. Not the automated mail three days later, when she is back at her desk and remembers a nice hotel by the sea. The person who was standing there, while she can still name the room.

Not the five stars. The stars are the part that feeds the score, and the score was for the human reader. Ask her for the cove, the room number, the manager who got her the table in the village, the Tuesday it rained and what you did about it. Specifics are the only part of a review that survives being compressed, because a specific is the one thing a summary cannot fold into every other summary. Her sentence about the corner room and the church bells is worth more to your hotel than forty perfect scores.

There is a second thing, and nobody has told hoteliers this one. Your most careful guest — the one who wants to do you justice — is now the likeliest to run her draft through a chatbot before posting. Tripadvisor removed 214,000 reviews in 2024 as machine-written, and its own head of trust and safety says most of them were not fake at all. Real guests, real stays, tidied prose, deleted.

The best night your hotel gave anyone last year is worth nothing to you until someone writes it down. Nobody will read what she writes. Everything that sells your rooms will.

Read also: Agoda now decides which of your reviews a traveler reads · Marriott says it already wins the AI answer. It's buying ads there anyway · Your AI recommendation is not for sale. But a resort like yours can earn it

Enjoying this analysis?* Hospitality.today delivers daily insights on hotel distribution, AI trends, and travel commerce — straight to your inbox. Subscribe for free at Hospitality.today →